8 Ways to Teach Your Feisty Toddler to Share

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details.

As soon as my toddler neared the double-digits, lots of new words began to grace her vocabulary. Along with cute and cuddly words like “doggy” and “kisses” came frustrating words like, “no!” and “mine!” 

And to make it worse, those frustrating words are being yelled at an obscene volume any time mom or dad asks a question or, God forbid, someone picks up something she wants. 

While I’m fortunate my feisty toddler’s development is on par, I’ve been working hard with her on the concept of sharing. Coming from a circus-like family with many brothers, sisters, and cousins, I had no choice but to share growing up. I guess you could say I’m pretty much a pro at sharing (and oversharing!)

Helping toddlers learn to share takes patience, cleverness, and calm coaching. But, don’t fret, your little one will get there soon enough.

toddler playing with xylophone

Here are 8 ways to teach your toddler how to share. 

Change Your Perspective

You’re going to have to change your perspective on the word “mine” or you’re going to go completely insane after hearing your toddler say it 230 times a day for the next few years. Everything within your toddler’s reach is now considered “mine.” Yes, even that delicious mug of coffee in your hand. Because whatever mom, dad, brother, sister, grandma, or her friend has, she wants.

Though my child says “mine” whenever she wants to hold, touch, or play with something, I’ve deciphered what she means to say is: “Mommy, I want this right NOW.”

So, I’ve begun responding to her exclamations as, “yes, you can play with that” or “no, you can’t play with that Chris is playing with that right now. You can play with this (grab another toy, etc.)”

During these moments, just try to focus on the concept of sharing. Sharing doesn’t happen overnight. Learning to be generous and empathetic towards others takes time, but the rest of these tips will help to speed it up. 

Lead by Example

Yes, leading by example is one of the obvious tips, but I find sometimes we need to be provided with explicit instructions for it to stay ingrained in our mushy mom brains. Make sharing an everyday practice in family life

During meal-time, start a designated “Sharing Stories” time where each person can share details of their day with no interruptions. Another opportunity at meal-time is to share food off your plate. Explain that, “Mama is sharing her mashed potatoes with Violet.” The next time, ask, “Will Violet share her crackers with Mama?” Give her kudos if she shares. 

Another example, outside of eating (sorry, I like to eat) is when my daughter is doodling. When she is drawing, I will ask her if she will share the pencil so I can draw a picture too. And, when she responds with “yes, mama” I am sure to thank her for sharing (and try not to explode with proud mama shrieks). 

Prep Before Playdates

If you’re hosting, tuck away your toddler’s favorite toy that she couldn’t stand to have someone else play with.

For my daughter, it’s her two lifelike baby dolls. She has like 10 baby dolls, but the big real ones are the ones she wants to play with every hour on the hour. If someone touches them, she will no doubt go awry. Once the favorite toys are tucked away safely, explain that the rest of the books and toys are for all her friends to enjoy. 

When you go to a play date at someone else’s house, first, talk about what to expect, then remind her of the fun toys to play with that involves sharing, like ball-rolling or building blocks. 

toddler playing with toy cars

Give Kudos 

When you witness your tiny tot sharing nicely with family members or other children, compliment them. Be specific and say, “You’re doing such a good job of sharing the Legos with Armin,” or “Wow, you are doing great playing dolls with Gracie.”

The positive reinforcement will help your child to remember the times that captured her mama’s positive attention and she’ll be more likely to repeat it at future meet-ups. 

Don’t Be a Rescue Ranger

It’s soooo hard. So. Dang. Hard. When your little one takes a toy from her sibling or friend, try not to jump in. Sit back and observe—see how the kiddos handle it. Most often they will keep on playing without a care in the world. 

Give your toddler a chance to work on her problem-solving skills. If we jump in all the time, our children will never learn how to work it out themselves. You may even be surprised at what solutions she comes up with on her own. 

Stop the Tears

When there are tears and/or physical harm involved, all matters should be addressed immediately.

If your child’s toy snatching is making her friend cry, remind her “That’s not nice. Ashley is playing with that,” then assist your child to find another toy or activity. 

When your child is in the opposite shoes, similarly, remove her from the situation and redirect her attention towards something else. 

Stand Firm on Hitting 

Hitting, pinching, or any other type of inappropriate physical contact requires an immediate response. If your toddler is the culprit, remove her from the situation and say, “We don’t hit. That hurts!” Most toddlers don’t yet understand the concept of apologizing and are often too embarrassed to comply if they do.

Instead, I’ll walk my daughter over to the friend, or family member, and apologize on her behalf. It’s important for your child to hear you acknowledge the bad behavior and that it is not okay. 

Related: 20 Toddler Discipline Strategies Every Mom Needs to Know

Experiment with Different Methods

Our children are as unique as the stars in the sky. Some approaches work well for one child, and for the next, you need to jump through fire hoops, smother yourself in war paint and run through cornfields, and other obscene acrobatics to provoke any type of positive response.

Experiment with various methods to see what works best for your child. If that means putting certain toys in time out when playmates are over or even playing Elmo and Ernie’s Sharing song before every dang play date, it’s worth a shot. 

While we say, “sharing is caring” and often make light of sharing in other ways, sharing is a lot more complex than parents make it out to be. 

It requires your toddler to understand the concept of lending or giving. It involves holding two ideas in a toddler’s little developing brain (The doll is mine, but my friend currently has it). It also requires a general understanding of time (My friend will return the doll later). Lastly, they must understand certain things shouldn’t be shared, like toothbrushes or underwear. 

That’s a lot to grasp for young developing minds. 

But, like with most everything in motherhood, with your patience, cleverness, and calm coaching, your child’s sharing abilities will soon shine bright and you’ll be left wondering why you even worried about all this stuff in the first place. 

two toddlers fighting over a doll

Share the love!

Author: Brandi Wiatrak

Hey, Mama! I'm Violet's mom and Chris' step-mama, Brandi. This space is a peek into my cold-brew fueled life navigating motherhood and the world. With brutal honesty, humor, and sarcasm, I talk about the joys (and sucks) of parenting, ways to live a simple & sane life, and awesome adventures to embark on with your family. Come aboard my crazy train! Wine and Gerber Puffs included.

Leave a Reply